Crafting a Stellar Comparison Essay: 2 Stories from “Essays for Writers

How to Write a Comparison Essay about 2 Stories from the Book “Essays for Writers”


Writing a comparison essay can be an exciting and insightful task, especially when analyzing two captivating stories from the book “Essays for Writers”. In this article, we will guide you through the process of crafting a top-notch comparison essay that highlights the similarities and differences between these two literary gems. By following our step-by-step instructions, you’ll be well-equipped to create a compelling essay that will impress both your readers and search engines.

Step 1: Choose Two Stories

The first step in writing a comparison essay is to carefully select two stories from the book “Essays for Writers”. Take your time to read through the book and identify two stories that share common themes, characters, or writing styles. This will allow you to draw meaningful comparisons and provide a comprehensive analysis in your essay.

Step 2: Understand the Stories

Before diving into writing, it’s crucial to thoroughly understand the chosen stories. Revisit each story, making note of key plot points, character development, and any literary devices used by the authors. By gaining a deep understanding of the stories, you’ll be able to effectively compare and contrast them in your essay.

Step 3: Identify Similarities and Differences

Once you have a solid grasp of the stories, it’s time to identify their similarities and differences. Look for common themes, motifs, or narrative structures that are present in both stories. Additionally, pay attention to the unique aspects of each story that set them apart. These comparisons will form the backbone of your essay.

Step 4: Develop a Thesis Statement

Crafting a strong thesis statement is essential in any essay, including a comparison essay. Your thesis statement should clearly state the main points of comparison between the two stories and provide a roadmap for your essay. Make sure it is concise, specific, and engaging to capture the attention of both readers and search engines.

Step 5: Outline Your Essay

To ensure a well-structured and coherent essay, it’s recommended to create an outline before diving into the writing process. Divide your essay into introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion. Each body paragraph should focus on a specific point of comparison, supported by evidence and analysis. This will provide a logical flow to your essay and make it easier for readers to follow your arguments.

Step 6: Write the Essay

Now that you have your outline, it’s time to start writing your comparison essay. Begin with a captivating introduction that hooks your readers and introduces the two stories you’ll be discussing. In the body paragraphs, present your points of comparison one by one, providing evidence from the stories and analyzing their significance. Finally, conclude your essay by summarizing your main points and reinforcing your thesis statement.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: How long should my comparison essay be?

A1: The length of your essay may vary depending on the requirements set by your instructor. However, a typical comparison essay is around 500-800 words. Remember to focus on quality rather than quantity, ensuring that your arguments are well-developed and supported.

Q2: Can I compare more than two stories in my essay?

A2: While it’s possible to compare more than two stories, it’s generally recommended to focus on two for a more in-depth analysis. Comparing too many stories in a single essay may lead to a lack of focus and depth in your analysis.

Q3: How do I choose the best stories for comparison?

A3: When selecting stories for comparison, consider the ones that share common themes, settings, or character arcs. Look for stories that provide ample material for analysis and offer interesting contrasts or similarities.

Q4: Should I focus more on similarities or differences?

A4: Both similarities and differences are crucial in a comparison essay. Strive for a balanced analysis that highlights both aspects. By exploring both similarities and differences, you’ll provide a comprehensive understanding of the stories.

Q5: Can I use quotes from the stories in my essay?

A5: Absolutely! Incorporating relevant quotes from the stories can strengthen your arguments and provide supporting evidence for your analysis. Ensure that you properly cite the quotes according to the required citation style.

Q6: How can I ensure my essay ranks highly on search engines?

A6: To optimize your essay for search engines, make sure to include relevant keywords in your headings, subheadings, and throughout the content. Additionally, focus on creating high-quality, original content that provides value to readers. Proper formatting, meta tags, and a user-friendly website will also contribute to better search engine rankings.

By following these guidelines, you’ll be well on your way to crafting a stellar comparison essay about two stories from the book “Essays for Writers”. Remember, the key is to provide insightful analysis, engage your readers, and optimize your content for search engines. Happy writing!